When Montgomery County in Maryland imposed a bill banning the use and holding of firearms within 100 yards of places of worship, it did not seem like there would be backlash that would concern a case regarding religious liberties. However, this past July, the New Civil Liberties Alliance filed suit against Montgomery County, stating that the bill was unconstitutional. The practicing members of the Silver Springs Jewish Center, stated that this bill goes against their religious beliefs. According to them, Jews are called to, “proactively provide their own security and security for other Jews.” It is believed that Jewish law compels their people to act in this way of security and that outsiders or other people (such as a security team) around their house of worship, does not fulfill these callings of having required security and protection over their own people. Since October 7th, 2023, the synagogue has created a security team that stands outside of the church, however, they say that this has, actually, only increased anti-semitic activity, and that a synagogue member was attacked outside while this security team was present. Because of many recent antisemitic threats both against the church and around the country, the members of the Silver Spring Jewish Center believe that their Free Exercise Rights are being infringed upon.
The constitutional issue in question is as follows: Does the Montgomery County gun bill that prevents firearms within 100 yards of a house of worship infringe on the Free Exercise Rights of the Jewish people who attend Silver Spring Jewish Center? Additionally, does this law disrespect the Establishment Clause by having the government make rules in place of the religious leaders of the synagogue?
Silver Spring Jewish Center, and the New Civil Liberties Alliance who is representing them, argue that this bill not only prevents them from participating in the act of protection their religion calls them to do, but also that they are being singled out as a religious institution. In light of the growing antisemitic attacks around the country, the members of Silver Spring Jewish Center believe that it is imperative to their safety, and the safety of those in the synagogue, that they are allowed to carry guns in, and around, the synagogue. They state that the bill forbidding them to do this is not only targeted, and not neutral, but also discriminates on the basis of beliefs. In terms of the issue of establishment, they claim that this bill disrespects their autonomy as a religious institution by not allowing religious leaders to make decisions that are best for their congregation (in this case, bringing firearms to the synagogue).
I think this a very interesting and complex case with many factors working against each other. Montgomery County has said that Bill 23-26 was enacted to keep places of public assembly safe, as they are places where children grow and families gather. The spaces that have this 100 yard restriction are houses of worship, schools, parks, and libraries. The creation of this bill stems from Montgomery County working to decrease gun violence across the county, especially in areas frequented by children.
After reading about the bill, its creation, and implications, I do not believe that this bill is unconstitutional. To start, I don’t think there is a very strong claim that there is an issue of establishment in this case. This bill does not instruct the leaders of the Silver Spring Jewish Center to do or not do anything. The bill is not being made with the purpose to overstep into the synagogue’s leadership and tell them what they can and cannot do. Even though leaders of a church do have say over what they instruct their congregation to do, a law passed concerning the good of an entire county does not over-step religious freedoms in terms of establishment. With that being said, I also do not think that there is an unconstitutional suppression of Free Exercise Rights. When looking at the case Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of Hialeah, there was a similar issue with laws being passed that inhibited Free Exercise Rights against religious groups to inhibit their worshiping. However, in that case, unlike this one, the laws were made in direct response to the church members moving into town and looking to set up a house of worship, therefore making the laws unconstitutional. In this case, the laws were made in order to curb gun violence in areas that are often inhabited by children and families. Although there is an indirect burden to the people of the synagogue by this bill, the state has a very strong compelling interest to protect spaces, such as houses of worship, from possible instances of gun violence.
I believe that Bill 23-26 is not an unconstitutional law made by Montgomery County. I do not find the issue of the establishment that the New Civil Liberties Alliance is claiming, of the government making rules in place of church leaders to be very compelling. When this law was made, they were not looking to “step on the toes” of religious leaders and churches. When viewing this from an issue of Free Exercise Rights, I understand the concern that the people of the synagogue feel it is their religious right and duty to protect themselves and other members of their congregation. However, I more importantly believe that the state has an extremely compelling state interest to regulate the possession of firearms in spaces such as houses of worship, to look out for the wellbeing and safety of the families who reside there.

I agree with your argument that Montgomery County's law is constitutional because it is neutral and applies to everyone. I think the county also has a compelling state interest in preventing gun violence and keeping the public safe. I understand that the law places a burden on members of the synagogue because they believe it is their religious responsibility to protect their community and they are worried about threats against Jewish people, but the law does not just apply to their synagogue or places of religion. It restricts firearms within 100 yards of other public spaces, including schools, parks, libraries, and other houses of worship. I think the law was put in place for a good reason and since it applies to everyone and does not provide exceptions I do not think they should be allowed to ignore it because of their religious beliefs. They can still take other measures to protect their synagogue and community while following the law.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your argument that Montgomery County’s law does not violate the Free Exercise Clause because it applies to both religious and secular spaces. It is important to recognize that the law was created to prevent gun violence rather than to restrict the religious practices of the Jewish community. I understand why the congregation wants to protect its members but religious beliefs don't automatically allow people to ignore laws that protect public safety. Also the fact that the law applies to schools, parks, and libraries, and not just houses of worship shows the government is sincerely addressing a public safety concern.
ReplyDeleteBrooke, I agree with your argument. As my peers have outlined, there is a clear and undoubtedly compelling state interest in monitoring the safety of the public of the Montgomery County law banning guns in this area. While I understand why this case is contentious, as there is also religious conviction of the Jewish Community in this area that makes its members feel as though carrying a firearm is necessary, the neutrality and purpose to protect public spaces both trump the claim that three First Amendment is violated
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your argument, especially your interpretation of the Establishment Clause. I do not believe the government is interfering with the authority of religious leaders simply by regulating firearms near places of worship. There is a difference between controlling how a religious organization operates and enforcing laws that protect the general public. I also liked your comparison to the Church of Lukumi case, because it demonstrates the importance of examining the government's intentions when determining whether a law is religiously neutral. Although the synagogue has legitimate concerns about its safety, I believe the county has a compelling interest in preventing gun violence.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your conclusion that the public safety concern of firearms being in a place that is inhabited by families and children is compelling enough to warrant a burden on the Free Exercise of the Silver Spring Jewish Center. In addition, I believe this law is the least restrictive means to accommodate the congregation's practice and the compelling state interest as they are still allowed to have security and other ways of protecting themselves, simply just not a firearm.
ReplyDelete