February 16th, 2016 a Missouri court rejected the primary claim of a fired ministry worker, Colleen Simon. Upon being fired, Simon filed a lawsuit against the diocese on the grounds that the administration ended her employment due to her same-sex marriage. Simon, a former Kansas City church worker, was employed by the St. Francis Xavier Church as a coordinator f
or the food pantry.
In the lawsuit, Simon declared that her supervisors at the church knew she was in a same-sex marriage and that it wasn’t an issue. However, two weeks after the Kansas City Star wrote an article in April 2014 about her marriage to Rev. Donna Simon of St. Mark Hope and Peace Lutheran Church in Kansas City Simon was fired.
In court, the Jackson County Judge wouldn’t consider Simon’s accusations of the priest’s supposed knowledge of her sexual orientation and ultimately her status as an employee because it “would impermissibly entangle the court in matters and deacons purely canonical.” Indeed, the legal representatives of the church believed this to be the most important part of the lawsuit. To allow for government intervention in church affairs would be to negate “the very line the First Amendment says the government cannot cross.” Moreover, the church fought extensively as to not let Simon’s case go to court in the first place for this very reason.
Personally, I don’t think the issue is wether the church had a right to fire Ms. Simon. It could be argued that she worked for the ministry, regardless of the role she played, any job under the ministry is a representation of the church’s values. However, this argument is clearly an issue within the church and only the church.
To that end, the most important and fundamental part of the entire lawsuit is that under the Free Exercise Clause the church has a right to strongly oppose government involvement in their decisions whether it be on employment or other religious matters. As stated, this is a direct and “excessive” entanglement of government in religious affairs. It is up to the church to freely exercise its beliefs and if they feel Simon, as an employee, goes against such beliefs then the administration has the power to make their own decisions on employment. The court did recognize this and affirmed the First Amendment by allowing the diocese to appropriately, under catholic teaching, decide employment status based on their own principles.
Thus, this case is fundamental in drawing the lawn as to where job discrimination against an individual based on their sexuality can be drawn and when it is permissible to have the government intervene in such a matter. As stated, I believe that in this particular case government intervention would be completely inappropriate when drawing upon the first amendment of the Constitution.



