Friday, February 19, 2016

School Choice or Violation of the First Amendment?

Last year Montana joined over 40 other states in implementing a program to help students and their families secure school choice. The Montana legislature passed a law creating a scholarship program that would be used to help families who could not afford to send their children to their school of choice. The scholarship program relied on donations from private individuals and businesses who would receive a tax credit up to $150 in return for their donation. Scholarships would then be distributed to help families send their children, grades K through 12,  to the private school of their choosing.


The new program was to go into effect on January 1st of this year. While many were initially excited about the school choice program, things became more complicated in December 2015. The Montana Department of Revenue made a rule saying that the scholarship program does not extend to any schools “owned or controlled in whole or in part by any church, religious sect, or denomination.” In the state of Montana, nearly two-thirds of private schools are religiously affiliated, so this rule majorly restricts the choices families have when using this scholarship program.

Following the implementation of this rule, a group of families and Christian schools have sued the Montana Department of Revenue. They are represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF), who strongly believes that this rule violates both the free exercise of religion and the establishment clause guaranteed by the First and Fourteenth Amendments. Just last week, the PLF testified in federal court aiming to get the Montana Revenue Service to freeze the rule until the details of the case have been decided. The Montana Revenue Service believes that this rule is a necessary edition to the tax-credit scholarship program in order to prevent public funds from being used to benefit religion. They argue that they are following the Montana State Constitution since it clearly forbids public funding of religious institutions.


The PLF argues that the claims of the Revenue Service are flawed since none of the money going into the scholarship fund is public money, but rather a private donation. Additionally, the government does not direct the money to a religious institution since the school choice is ultimately up to the student receiving the scholarship and his family. The PLF believes that this rule causes families who need financial assistance for schooling to feel pressured to abandon their desire to attend a religious school. Furthermore, schools looking to attract students who need financial assistance will need to abandon their religious affiliation in order to do so. The PLF sees this as a clear violation of the Free Exercise of religion. In terms of the establishment clause, they argue that religious schools are being denied benefits solely because of their religious beliefs, which they see as an unfair favoring of secular schools.

The main issues in this case come down to two questions: Is prohibiting private religious schools from this scholarship program an unconstitutional violation of the free exercise and establishment clauses? And, would the government be illegally funding religion by providing tax-credits to individuals who make private donations to a scholarship fund that may help students to attend a religious school?

I believe that excluding religious schools from this scholarship program is an unconstitutional violation of the first amendment on behalf of students. A very important point to consider here is what constitutes public aid of a religion. If the government were giving religious schools money to use as scholarships to attract students, then the government would be aiding religion beyond their ability. However, in this case, the scholarship money does not at all come directly from the government. The scholarship money comes completely from individuals who freely choose to donate to the fund.  The so-called “aid” only results from the tax-credit that individuals receive after making their donation. This tax-credit does not go to a religious school, but rather back to the individual who chose to make the donation. No public funds are used to finance a scholarship, so the state of Montana is not using public funds to support a religious institution in any way and therefore is not violating its state Constitution or the 14th amendment.

This case is similar to the case of Everson v. Board of Education of Ewing Township, which held that reimbursing parents of students for public transportation to a religious school is not unconstitutional. The court ruled that the First amendment does not prohibit this general program that extended to public and other schools. Families could not be excluded from these transportation reimbursements because of their religion as this would inhibit their free exercise and would be an unequal treatment of religion and non-religion. Similarly, in this case, religious private schools should not be prohibited from a general scholarship program that applies to all private schools. This would be limiting free exercise of religion for families choosing their schools because they may feel pressured to abandon their desire to attend a religious school in order to obtain a scholarship. Furthermore, this would not represent a neutral stance between religious and non-religious private schools since religious private schools are being excluded from a program solely because of their religion. The lack of a neutral stance between religion and non-religion violates the establishment clause of the first amendment, just as it did in Everson v. Board of Education of Ewing Township.

Overall, I believe that the rule prohibiting religious schools from this scholarship program is faulty on a few accounts. First, the Department of Revenue’s claim that the program would be an illegal public funding and support of religion is wrong since the scholarships come from completely private donations and the tax-credits go to individuals who make the donations, not the schools. Second, eliminating religious schools from the program inhibits free exercise of religion by pressuring students who need financial assistance not to choose a religious school. Lastly, in restricting religious schools from participating in this program, the government is not maintaining neutrality between religion and non-religion, as the establishment clause suggests it should. For these reasons, I believe that the Department of Revenue’s rule violates both the free exercise and establishment clauses of the First Amendment and that repealing the rule would not lead to an illegal funding of religious institutions by the Montana state government. 


So, what do you think?

Monday, February 15, 2016

How Much Freedom Is Too Much Freedom In Schools?

A new bill, House Bill 425, in Ohio extends students’ freedom to express religion during the school day. Current law limits religious expression to periods of time when students are otherwise free from academic duties but restricts students from expressing themselves religiously in class and other academic settings.  This new bill states that students can engage in religiously oriented activities and expression in the form of prayer, gatherings, distribution of materials, voiced opinions, and clothing “before, during, and after school hours … to the same extent that a student is permitted to engage in secular activities.”

This bill is met with some challenges, as illustrated by Gary Daniels of ACLU in Ohio. He, as well as David Tryon, a lawyer and former president of the Brecksville-Broadview Heights Board of Education in northeastern Ohio, question the bill by pointing out its redundancies. The First Amendment already guarantees students the right to free expression in school in the form of clubs, private prayer, and religious wear. The two claim that the bill is unnecessary because it only restates these already established rights. However Daniels also questions this bill on the bases of the slippery slope. This bill is very liberal in its acceptance of religious expression, granting students the right to show their religious views even in homework assignments. Daniels argues that if students are given this right, there is nothing stopping a biology student from turning in a paper claiming creationism to be truth during a unit on evolution without penalization, since this is not science. He says that this then becomes an open question under the bill, with no definitive conclusion.

I agree that this bill is both repetitive in some aspects and too broad in others. I agree whole-heartedly with giving students the right to free expression in schools in the form of clubs, religious wear, and in some cases the right to express views in homework assignments. This last point is where the slippery slope comes in. As Daniels said, what conclusion could be made if a student submits a paper on creationism for his evolution assignment? Could the student be penalized because this is not science and doesn’t fit into the assignment, or is the student protected under this bill? Although I agree with the right to show religious views in assignments I realize that this is a very slippery topic because I don’t think that the student who turns in this paper during the evolution unit should receive full credit because that goes against the point of the unit. The bill also allows teachers to take time during class to do activities of a “moral, philosophical or patriotic theme.” I also disagree with this new privilege. Schools should not be providing moral instruction to students, I don’t think that teachers should be allowed to take time out of class to stress their own moral or philosophical views. This could easily lead to preaching in classrooms and indoctrination in schools. This is the very thing that providing rules that regulate religious expression in schools are aimed to do, and I feel that this bill can easily lend itself to getting around this protection against religious teaching in school.

There are parts of this bill that I think will do good, though. Although students already have the right to form religious groups in school, this broader bill may make that right more clear and harder to challenge. An example given in the article is a 2015 graduate, Kelly Haight, who had to seek legal help so that her religiously oriented club could use the school auditorium for one of their events. I feel that with a more broad bill firmly established, this would not happen. Since the student-run club just wanted to use the auditorium, they should have been allowed. Any other school club would be granted the use of facilities to hold events for their activities, and I feel that this was no exception. I think that with a bill like this in place there would be no way for the school to deny this use of facilities.

Overall I think this is a well-intentioned bill that will do plenty of good for students wishing to express their beliefs in school, but I feel like it does lend itself to the slippery slope argument. Maybe this could be ironed out with a few adjustments, but in the meantime, what do you think? Is this bill simply redundant? Does it provide more good to the students, or does it take away from learning? 

Sunday, February 14, 2016

Favoring non-religion over religion?

Earlier in February, the City Council of Phoenix voted to change the meetings' opening ceremony. The meetings, which used to be opened with a prayer, are now opened with a moment of silence. This change was fueled by the intentions of a Satanistic group to lead the opening prayer. The Satanists were scheduled to lead prayer on February 17th. Any religious group was allowed to lead the opening prayer if they asked the council to do so. Some members of the Council, including Sal DiCicco, looked to stop the Satanists from leading prayer because they believed that this would not be a good image for the city. The issue was brought to court and passed with an emergency clause which allows the law to be effective within 24 hours. This prevented the Satanists from going forward with leading the prayer.

DiCicco voiced his opinion stating that "it's a dumb idea, we do not have to legally do this, and they're not a recognized religion". He wanted to change the rule so that the prayers had to be pre-approved in order to be said at council meetings. However, it was recommended by Councilwoman Thelda Williams to go with an "all or nothing" approach in order to avoid issues of constitutionality. The alternative was getting rid of prayer all together. Now groups are free to lead the invocation with a moment of silence but they are no longer permitted to vocalize the ideals of their religion through prayer. Members of this Satanistic group are disappointed with the council's decision because all they wanted to do was participate in the same way as so many other religious groups have. The group does not believe in any religious figure and is therefore an atheistic group that sees satan as a metaphor for religious tyranny. They wanted to deliver a two minute prayer that encompassed their beliefs in a very non-coercive way.

There is a lot of controversy among religious leaders regarding this new rule. Over 50 different people, including many religious leaders, gathered to discuss this change in an emotionally charged conversation that cited references including scripture and the U.S. Constitution. Pastor Darlene Vazquez was extremely disappointed with the change saying that, "I want those who believe in one true God to pray. It breaks my heart to hear what is going on". However, the council ensures that this change is in everyone's best interest and is fair to all.

A past Supreme Court Case, Town of Greece v. Galloway, decided that in New York it is not unconstitutional to open legislative sessions in prayer as long as they are not discriminatory against minority religions. But can this situation in Phoenix not be seen as discrimination against minority religious groups? There has never been an issue with the opening prayer until this minority group of Satanists decided to embrace the same opportunity as other religious groups.

Does the council's decision to change a long-standing tradition in order to prevent the prayers of Satanists go against the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment? The clause states that not only can no one religion be favored over another, but there can also be no discrimination between religion and non-religion. In the case of the City Council of Phoenix, religion is being discriminated against and non-religion is being favored. Just because Satanists are a minority religion and their beliefs are not generally accepted and practiced, should they be denied the same opportunities as other, less controversial religions?

Can NASA Ban Jesus?

This past week, NASA decided that the use of the word “Jesus” is not to be permitted in the Johnson Space Center newsletter, a newsletter that is sent out electronically to all employees. The newsletter contains messages from any club that chooses to submit and announces upcoming events. The Worship and Praise Club meets to discuss their Christian faith, and the meetings are open to any employees of any religion. Last May, they announced this message in the newsletter:

“Join with the praise and worship band “Allied with the Lord” for a refreshing set of spring praise and worship songs on Thursday, June 4, from 11:15 a.m. to noon in Building 57, Room 106. (The theme for this session will be “Jesus is our life!”) Prayer partners will be available for anyone who has need. All JSC civil servants and contractors are welcome.”

The legal department of NASA called the organization soon after and asked them to remove the word “Jesus” on the basis that allowing it constituted an establishment of religion, thus violating the First Amendment. The club offered to provide a disclaimer that the words were not affiliated with NASA but rather was private speech, but the legal department said that this suggestion to provide a disclaimer was “insufficient” and not accepted. The club has now brought lawsuit to NASA, saying that this censorship is inflicting upon the free speech and religion of the members. 

Though not entirely the same, this case reminded me of the Supreme Court decision in Everson v.Board of Education of Ewing Township, which is a landmark case for the establishment of religion. The township passed a law to reimburse the parents of students who took buses to and from both public and Catholic schools. The Court ruled this constitutional and said in the majority opinion that by allowing the reimbursements of both types of schools, the state was remaining neutral to religion. If the state did not give the reimbursements to the Catholic schools, they would be disadvantaging a religion. To compare, by not allowing the word “Jesus” in the newsletter, NASA is disadvantaging a religion and giving free speech rights only to other non-religious groups. Both surround the issue of the establishment of a religion.

NASA should not be censoring the word “Jesus” from the Johnson Space Center newsletter for a number of reasons. To begin, the legal department used the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment as justification for not allowing the word. However, just the word “Jesus” itself is not religious in nature, although affiliated with a number of religions. And in this context, the group was not saying that anyone in attendance had to believe in him or had to pray, but rather expressed their own views. By censoring the newsletter for this religious group, NASA is infringing upon the free speech clause of the First Amendment as well. It is clearly stated that the ideas, opinions, and interests of the club are those of the club alone and not affiliated with the beliefs of the NASA organization itself.  

In addition, according to the majority opinion written by Justice Black in the Everson v. Board of Education of Ewing Township, “the ‘establishment of religion’ clause of the First Amendment means at least this…neither a state nor the Federal Government can, openly or secretly, participate in the affairs of any religious organizations or groups and vice versa”. This can be applied to the case here. While NASA is neither a state nor the federal government, it is acting as the governing body of the Worship and Praise Club. NASA should not have the authority to tell this club what they are allowed to say in the newsletter, especially because the club is separate from NASA.


What do you think? Does NASA have the right to censor the newsletter that is sent out to all of its employees? Does this violate the First Amendment of the United States Constitution? Is allowing the word “Jesus” to be used an establishment of religion?

Should Religious Establishments be Allowed to Freely Express their Political Opinions?



Election years for the President of the United States symbolizes a time for American to express their opinions on various issues and help shape the agenda for the next Commander in Chief. This year, the American public has placed emphasis on immigration reform, handling the global conflict with ISIS, and the possible continuance of the Affordable Care Act. However, what happens when your voice can't be heard at the polls?

American places of worship are among some of the most prominent entities that cannot participate in the 2016 election. According to the rules of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), churches and other places of worship are charitable organizations that receive tax exempt status (Section 501(c)(3)). To qualify as a charitable organization, an organization’s purpose must fulfill one of the following goals: “relief of the poor, the distressed, or the underprivileged; advancement of religion; advancement of education or science; erecting or maintaining public buildings, monuments, or works; lessening the burdens of government; lessening neighborhood tensions; eliminating prejudice and discrimination; defending human and civil rights secured by law; and combating community deterioration and juvenile delinquency.” A downside to qualifying for this exemption is that “organizations are absolutely prohibited from directly or indirectly participating in, or intervening in, any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for executive public office.” This exemption stems from the Constitution Framers intentions of keeping religious and governmental institutions separate. The IRS does allow for religious places of worship to perform “certain voter education activities conducted in a non partisan manner.”

Matt Barber, a constitutional law political analyst, feels that American churches and other places of worship should play a greater role in American politics. Barber believes that righteousness and morality, not economic or military factors are the primary strengths for a nation. Those strengths can be derived from the religions practiced within a nation. He accuses the United States in participating a “religious cleansing campaign” backed by the Establishment Clause. The Establishment Clause states “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion…” and organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union and Americans United are using this provision to encourage governments to be critical of religions. In his final statements in the article, he encourages religious groups to directly endorse candidates who share their beliefs and defy the tax exempt restrictions set forth by the IRS. Barber notes that the IRS has no mechanism to take away a church’s tax exempt status. Barber also believes that pastors can help encourage participation in the American electorate on several types of issues, urge people to register and vote, and distribute guides.

Americans United, a group advocating the separation of church and state, was understandably upset at Barber’s suggestion. The AU also believe they are following the intentions of Thomas Jefferson, who wanted no intersection of duties between religions and the central government. Jefferson and James Madison believed that no lawmaker could be unbiased on the matter of determining which religions were acceptable for the young nation. Simon Brown believes that while the phrase separation of church and state isn’t in the Constitution, the idea for separate institutions was a popular belief of the Founders. The AU also believe that the IRS has the power to take away an establishment’s tax exempt status and cites the Church at Pierce Creek as a prior example. In 1992, the Church ran newspaper ads that told people to not vote for Democratic nominee Bill Clinton. As a result, it lost its tax exempt status in 1995.

I believe that places of worship do not have a right to express their opinions under the Free Exercise Clause and the Establishment Clause. These important clauses from the 1st and 14th Amendments demand that no religion be held superior to any other, advance the practice of certain religions, or hinder the progress of others in any federal or state jurisdictions. In addition, the eventual winner of the election would in good conscience make sure to appease all constituents that voted for them. If a certain religious group supports a campaign, the newly elected President. would be tempted to create legislation that supports religion. This action as declared in the 1947 Supreme Court case McCollum v. Board of Education is unconstitutional. The Supreme Court at that time ruled that “no tax in any amount, large or small, can be levied to support any religious activities or institutions.”


So what ultimately is the right path in your opinion? Should American places of worship express their opinions in this crucial election or is it more important churches to keep their tax exempt status?