Last year Montana joined over 40
other states in implementing a program to help students and their families
secure school choice. The Montana legislature passed a law creating a
scholarship program that would be used to help families who could not afford to
send their children to their school of choice. The scholarship program relied
on donations from private individuals and businesses who would receive a
tax credit up to $150 in return for their donation. Scholarships would then be
distributed to help families send their children, grades K through 12, to the private school of their choosing.
The new program was to go into
effect on January 1st of this year. While many were initially
excited about the school choice program, things became more complicated in December
2015. The Montana Department of Revenue made a rule saying that the scholarship
program does not extend to any schools “owned or controlled in whole or in part
by any church, religious sect, or denomination.” In the state of Montana,
nearly two-thirds of private schools are religiously affiliated, so this rule
majorly restricts the choices families have when using this scholarship
program.
Following the implementation of
this rule, a group of families and Christian schools have sued the Montana Department
of Revenue. They are represented by the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF), who
strongly believes that this rule violates both the free exercise of religion
and the establishment clause guaranteed by the First and Fourteenth Amendments.
Just last week, the PLF testified in federal court aiming to get the Montana
Revenue Service to freeze the rule until the details of the case have been
decided. The Montana Revenue Service believes that this rule is a necessary
edition to the tax-credit scholarship program in order to prevent public funds
from being used to benefit religion. They argue that they are following the
Montana State Constitution since it clearly forbids public funding of religious
institutions.
The PLF argues that the claims of
the Revenue Service are flawed since none of the money going into the
scholarship fund is public money, but rather a private donation. Additionally,
the government does not direct the money to a religious institution since the
school choice is ultimately up to the student receiving the scholarship and his
family. The PLF believes that this rule causes families who need financial
assistance for schooling to feel pressured to abandon their desire to attend a
religious school. Furthermore, schools looking to attract students who need
financial assistance will need to abandon their religious affiliation in order
to do so. The PLF sees this as a clear violation of the Free Exercise of
religion. In terms of the establishment clause, they argue that religious
schools are being denied benefits solely because of their religious beliefs,
which they see as an unfair favoring of secular schools.
The main issues in this case come
down to two questions: Is prohibiting private religious schools from this
scholarship program an unconstitutional violation of the free exercise and
establishment clauses? And, would the government be illegally funding religion
by providing tax-credits to individuals who make private donations to a
scholarship fund that may help students to attend a religious school?
I believe that excluding religious
schools from this scholarship program is an unconstitutional violation of the
first amendment on behalf of students. A very important point to consider here
is what constitutes public aid of a religion. If the government were giving
religious schools money to use as scholarships to attract students, then the
government would be aiding religion beyond their ability. However, in this
case, the scholarship money does not at all come directly from the government.
The scholarship money comes completely from individuals who freely choose to
donate to the fund. The so-called “aid”
only results from the tax-credit that individuals receive after making their
donation. This tax-credit does not go to a religious school, but rather back to
the individual who chose to make the donation. No public funds are used to
finance a scholarship, so the state of Montana is not using public funds to
support a religious institution in any way and therefore is not violating its
state Constitution or the 14th amendment.
This case is similar to the case of
Everson v. Board of Education of Ewing
Township, which held that
reimbursing parents of students for public transportation to a religious school
is not unconstitutional. The court ruled that the First amendment does not
prohibit this general program that extended to public and other schools.
Families could not be excluded from these transportation reimbursements because
of their religion as this would inhibit their free exercise and would be an
unequal treatment of religion and non-religion. Similarly, in this case,
religious private schools should not be prohibited from a general scholarship
program that applies to all private schools. This would be limiting free
exercise of religion for families choosing their schools because they may feel
pressured to abandon their desire to attend a religious school in order to
obtain a scholarship. Furthermore, this would not represent a neutral stance
between religious and non-religious private schools since religious private
schools are being excluded from a program solely because of their religion. The
lack of a neutral stance between religion and non-religion violates the
establishment clause of the first amendment, just as it did in Everson v. Board of Education of Ewing
Township.
Overall, I believe that the rule
prohibiting religious schools from this scholarship program is faulty on a few
accounts. First, the Department of Revenue’s claim that the program would be an
illegal public funding and support of religion is wrong since the scholarships
come from completely private donations and the tax-credits go to individuals
who make the donations, not the schools. Second, eliminating religious schools
from the program inhibits free exercise of religion by pressuring students who
need financial assistance not to choose a religious school. Lastly, in
restricting religious schools from participating in this program, the
government is not maintaining neutrality between religion and non-religion, as
the establishment clause suggests it should. For these reasons, I believe that
the Department of Revenue’s rule violates both the free exercise and
establishment clauses of the First Amendment and that repealing the rule would
not lead to an illegal funding of religious institutions by the Montana state
government.
So, what do you think?



